We offer handmade pies, cupcakes, brownies and bar cookies. Our treats are made in small-batches, from scratch with locally sourced dairy, eggs, fruits and other ingredients.  We offer some vegan cupcakes and pies each day.  Folllow us on Twitter to see our daily offerings

 

Looking for something special? We require 48 hours notice but we will gladly make whole pies and cupcakes for you to take home.  We offer the following flavors of cupcakes and pies for special order…the (v) means a vegan version can be made…

 

PIES

  • Key Lime
  • Chocolate Cream
  • Banana Cream
  • Almond Cream
  • Almond Banana Chocolate Cream
  • Coconut Cream
  • Black Bottom Banana Cream
  • Caramel Banana Coconut Cream
  • Cookies and Cream
  • Butter Pecan Cream
  • Butterscotch Cream
  • Milwaukee Mud
  • Almond Joy
  • Smores
  • Millionaire
  • Lemon
  • Cherry (v)
  • Apple (v)
  • Cheddar Bacon Apple
  • Mixed Berry (v)
  • Cherry Berry (v)
  • Blueberry (v)
  • Peach Raspberry (v)
  • Peach (v)
  • Cherry Peach (v)
  • Bourbon Walnut Pecan
  • Pumpkin
  • Pumpkin Streusal
  • Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

 

CUPCAKES

  • Red Velvet (v)
  • Banana Chocolate Chip (v)
  • Double Chocolate (v)
  • Smores
  • Chocolate Mint (v)
  • Cookies and Cream (v)
  • Mexican Chocolate (v)
  • Vanilla Birthday
  • Pistachio Rose (v)
  • Chai (v)
  • Pumpkin (v)
  • Carrot
  • Chocolate Malt
  • Lemon
  • German Chocolate (v)
  • Vanilla Chocolate Chip
  • Chocolate Almond Cream (v)
  • Black Forest (v)
  • Mocha (v)
  • Chocolate Raspberry (v)
  • Chocolate w/Vanilla Frosting (v)
  • Vanilla w/Chocolate Frosting
  • Strawberry

Please know, we are a very tiny bakeshop whose primary focus is baking for a restaurant so our capacity for special orders fills up very quickly. As much as we love to crank out pies and cupcakes for big events we unfortunately do not have much space in our kitchen to do larger orders in addition to what we produce daily for the cafe.  We generally can only do special orders of 4 dozen cupcakes or less and 5 pies or less.  Anything larger please give us a call to discuss -  414-489-7437.

 

PRICING

 

  • 9″ Pie (six large slices/8 smaller slices) $26
  • Restaurant Sized Cupcakes – $18 half dozen
  • Restaurant Sized Cupcakes – $30 per dozen
  • Normal Person Sized Cupcakes (these are about as big as you’d make at home) – $20 dozen