Our treats are made in small-batches, from scratch with locally sourced dairy, eggs, fruits and other ingredients.  Follow us on Twitter to see our daily offerings | Follow @HoneypieCafe

Looking for something special? We ask for 48 hours notice.  We can make whole pies, cupcakes, cookies, biscuits and more for you to take home.  We offer a wide variety of flavors for special order...the (v) means a vegan version can be made.  If you do not see a flavor listed below that you have had at the restaurant, please feel free to ask. Please email or call us to discuss what you're looking for (see the bottom of this page for a a bit more info on larger special orders).  Place your order online here if you’re ready!

WE CAN DELIVER!  If you are interested in having a pie or a special order delivered in the Milwaukee area - we deliver via our friends at Forward Courier.  Delivery fees vary by address and quantity. 



11" Fruit Pie (vegan optional - 8 large slices/12 small slices) $29-$34

11" Cream Pie - Graham, Ginger or Chocolate Cookie Crust (8 large slices/12 small slices) $34

11” Cream Pie - Walnut Crust (gluten free - 8 large slices, 12 smaller slices) $40

Restaurant Sized Cupcakes | $20 half dozen (one flavor per half dozen)

Standard Sized Cupcakes (about as big as you'd make at home, only one flavor per dozen) |  $24 dozen

Big Cookies |  $12 per half dozen

Brownies/Bar Cookies | large 4", $24 half dozen (may be cut into smaller pieces)

IMPORTANT INFO ABOUT LARGER SPECIAL ORDERS - > Honeypie LOVES to do special orders for weddings, birthdays and events.  We are however a tiny bakeshop inside of a bustling restaurant - we are not quite a "traditional" bakery, or wedding cake maker or dessert caterer.  We are just a few hard workin' bakers who love to make delicious hand-made sweets.  So, if you are unfamiliar with who we are - there are a few things we'd like you to know because we have some limitations due to our size and location.  We hope you understand! 

Here they are... 

1 - We are not able to offer "tastings" in the same way that other traditional bakeries are able to.  We love to offer them - but we can only do up to 5-6 flavors/items that you'd like to try at a time.   We will make up a box of samples for you to pick up and try at home at your convenience.  We do not increase our prices for wedding/event orders and we don't want to!  Therefore, we do charge per item for our tastings.  We need about a week heads up for a tasting order but can have them ready for you any day of the week for pick up.

2 - We have a limit to how many special orders we can take at a time.  So place your order as early as you can.  You can choose exact flavors closer to the event date.  We just need to know if you're thinking pies or cupcakes and a rough quantity.  We do require full payment about a week prior to your order being completed.  We will email an invoice for online payment.

3 - At the moment, we do not have the space to do layer cakes - as much as we'd like to do them we have stopped offering them for the time being. We do still offer our cupcakes!

4 - We do partner with a local courier who can deliver your order in the Milwaukee area.  Let us know where you'd like a delivery made and we will inquire with them on pricing and availability and set it up for you.

5 - We do not pre-cut pies. Pies should not be cut until just prior to serving so your slices will hold up!

Give us a call with any questions you have.  We'd love to make some treats for your special day.