September: Specials of the Month

Specials of the Month
Written By PIE Inc.

September just got a whole lot cozier at Honeypie!

As the leaves begin their colorful transformation and that first hint of autumn crispness fills the air, we're celebrating the season with scratch-made specials that honor both tradition and innovation. Our kitchen team has been channeling their creativity into elevated comfort classics that capture everything we love about fall in Milwaukee—warmth, nostalgia, and that perfect balance of familiar and fresh.

Togarashi Fried Chicken sandwich with fries and house-made pickles at Honeypie

Food
_____

Togarashi Fried Chicken Sandwich

The perfect way to close out summer while welcoming fall—with just the right amount of heat.

Our September star features togarashi, a Japanese spice blend that brings gentle warmth without overwhelming, showcasing our favorite local purveyors in every bite.

Togarashi Fried Chicken, Blistered Shishito Aioli, Ginger Pickled Daikon Radish, Shredded Napa Cabbage, Cilantro.

Togarashi Fried Seitan sandwich in Honeypie's kitchen

Can also be made VEGAN!

sub the chicken patty with our house-made seitan!

Ready to spice up your September?
Order now for pickup or dine in with us.

 
Bittersweet Company cocktail and Caramel Apple Latte in Honeypie's dining room

Drinks


____

From the Bar: Bittersweet Company

Summer's Final Farewell! Enjoy a floral and slightly bitter sendoff as we start to chill out for fall.

Espolon Blanco, Campari, Elderflower, Lemon, Plum Bitters

From the Café: Caramel Apple Latte

NEEDS DESCRIPTION

Need a little extra boost?

Monin Caramel and Granny Smith Syrups, Sugar Leaf Coffee, & Oat Milk, Available Hot or Iced.

Other September Goodness

  • Don't miss September PIE of the MONTH from our bakers at Honeypie Bakeshop—the perfect sweet ending to any meal

  • Want to join us off-site? On September 14th, 2025, Honeypie Cafe is proud to join forces with 16 other women-led businesses for "Barefoot on the Farm" – an outdoor, family-style dinner that's so much more than just a meal. Learn more here

  • Mark your calendars: Beet Street returns Saturday 10/04, bringing back our beloved Annual Midwest Pie Championship after last year's hiatus. Stay tuned for delicious details!

 

As we transition into fall, we invite you to make Honeypie part of your September story. Whether you're catching up with old friends over brunch, treating yourself to a weekday lunch, or bringing the family for a cozy dinner, our September specials are here to make your moments more memorable. After all, comfort food tastes even better when it's shared in a space that feels like home—just a little finer.

If you’d like to stay updated with our Stuff of the Month here at Honeypie and across all PIE INC Locations, consider signing up for our newsletter below! Some additional goodies may be in your future…

PIE Inc.
Next

SEPTEMBER: Pie of the Month